Nexus of Violence and Mental Health Among Women in India

The National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5) sheds light on the grim reality of violence against women in India, revealing that nearly 30% of women aged 18-49 have encountered physical violence since the age of 15, with 6% reporting sexual violence. This unsettling trend underscores the intricate interplay between violence, mental health, and homelessness, a phenomenon observed over three decades of engagement with homeless women at The Banyan.

Understanding the Dynamics

• Recursive Interaction: Evidence suggests a reciprocal relationship between violence and mental health conditions, significantly heightening the risk of homelessness. The experiences of women accessing care at The Banyan illustrate how relational disruptions, often stemming from violence, predict homelessness, despite receiving mental health support.
• Qualitative Insights: Interviews with women living with mental health conditions unveil harrowing narratives of trauma and escape from cycles of violence. From predatory family members to controlling spouses, the impact of abuse, particularly child sexual abuse and intimate partner violence, reverberates throughout their journey into homelessness.

Personal Narratives

• Leela’s story epitomizes the struggles faced by homeless women with mental illness, escaping abusive environments only to grapple with the harsh realities of street survival. Her mother, Jaya, symbolizes the countless women forced into desperation by relentless violence, leaving behind scars both physical and emotional.

Structural Barriers and Agency:

• Poverty, caste, and societal norms perpetuate a cycle of violence, stripping women of agency and forcing them to sever traditional bonds of safety and belonging. Ellen Corrin’s research on social withdrawal in schizophrenia offers a nuanced lens to understand the complexities of women’s mental health, homelessness, and violence, emphasizing the importance of considering personal experiences within the broader context of societal constraints.

Reframing Madness- Women’s Response to Patriarchy

“Madness” has been a tool to silence women who defy gender norms. From witch hunts to asylums, intellectual women were deemed mentally ill. In patriarchal societies, “womanhood” is rigidly defined, confining women to reproductive roles and accepting violence. Here, “madness” isn’t a personal failing, but a spectrum of responses to societal oppression.

Resistance and Redefinition: Some see “madness” as resistance, a chance to break free from imposed identities and forge new paths.

Seeking Refuge: Others use “madness” to construct alternate realities, finding solace and empowerment in narratives of power or elaborate rituals.

Introspection: For some, “madness” is a journey inward, using altered perceptions to explore alternative realities free from societal constraints.

These experiences expose the limitations of the “madness” label. It fails to capture the richness of women’s resistance against a system of control. “Madness” becomes a multifaceted response – survival strategies, personal transformation, and a fight for self-determination. By acknowledging its complexity, we move beyond labels and gain a deeper understanding of women’s struggles.

Beyond Labels: A Complex Narrative

The mainstream conversation on women’s mental health often focuses on diagnoses like depression or anxiety, neglecting the broader social context. These experiences deserve attention, but not in isolation. A crucial element missing is the impact of violence against women and how it contributes to mental distress.

Biomedical Bias and Systemic Neglect

Current mental health and social care systems often reflect this limited view. They focus on symptoms and diagnoses rather than the lived experiences of women. Poverty and marginalization further complicate access to proper care, increasing the risk of homelessness. Women often encounter a system dismissive of their reality, seeking to erase their experiences instead of addressing them.

Moving Beyond Band-Aid Solutions

Investing solely in access to care isn’t enough. We need a comprehensive approach that tackles the root causes of violence. This includes:

• Recognizing Unpaid Labor: Valuing women’s domestic contributions can empower them economically.
• Building Supportive Networks: Creating safe spaces for women outside traditional family structures can provide refuge.
• Economic Empowerment: Basic income, housing opportunities, and land ownership can reduce homelessness risks.
• Education for Change: Curriculum challenging harmful gender norms can foster a generation that rejects violence against women.

Early Intervention is Key

Research by Robert Sapolsky suggests our choices are shaped by early experiences: abuse, neglect, and poverty can leave lasting scars on the developing brain. Policies and interventions that reduce violence in childhood can have a profound impact.

Multifaceted Approach is Essential

The complex relationship between violence, mental health, and homelessness requires a nuanced understanding. We need:

• Diverse Perspectives: Involving a range of professionals and those with lived experiences enriches the conversation.
• Innovative Research: Exploring the influence of phenomena like intersectionality and power dynamics is crucial.
• Feminist Standpoint Theory: Understanding knowledge from women’s experiences offers valuable insights.

Constitutional Provisions for the Protection of Women in India

• Article 14: Ensures equality before the law and equal protection of laws within the territory of India for both men and women.
• Article 15(1): Prohibits discrimination against any citizen on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, etc., promoting gender equality.
• Article 15(3): Allows the State to make special provisions for women, enabling affirmative action to combat historical inequalities.
• Article 16: Mandates equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the State.
• Article 23: Prohibits traffic in human beings and forced labor, indirectly safeguarding women from such exploitation.
• Article 39(a) and (d): Directs the State to ensure that men and women equally have the right to an adequate means of livelihood and to equal pay for equal work, respectively.
• Article 42: Advocates for just and humane conditions of work and maternity relief, recognizing the unique needs of working women.
• Article 51(A)(e): Encourages promoting harmony and the dignity of women by renouncing practices derogatory to women’s dignity.
• Articles 243D(3) & 243T(3): Mandate not less than one-third reservation for women in Panchayat and Municipal elections, promoting political participation at the grassroots and urban local body levels, respectively.

Conclusion: The intricate web of violence, homelessness, and mental health among women in India demands multifaceted interventions addressing structural barriers while prioritizing survivors’ agency and lived experiences. By amplifying voices and embracing nuanced perspectives, we can work towards fostering environments of safety, support, and empowerment for vulnerable women across the nation.

Check for More Current Affairs