Preventive Detention: A Necessary Evil_00.1
UPSC Exam   »   How to Prepare for UPSC CSE Mains Examination: Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners   »   Preventive Detention: A Necessary Evil

Preventive Detention: A Necessary Evil

 

Relevance

GS 2: Indian Constitution—historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.

 

Context

  • Recently, a bench of Supreme Court judges ruled that Preventive Detention (PD) should be used only when the detenu is affecting or is likely to affect public order.

 

Key points of the ruling

  • The Court maintained that PD is a necessary evil and must be used only to prevent public disorder.
  • PD is not synonymous with the ordinary detention.
  • The State must not use PD arbitrarily to deal with the law-and-order problems.
  • When a court deals with the PD, one of the foremost questions that need to be asked is whether the ordinary law of the land was sufficient to deal with the situation.
    • If the answer is yes, then PD will be declared illegal.

 

What is preventive detention?

  • Preventive detention means detaining an individual who has not yet committed any crime but the administration is of the opinion that, he/she is a threat and, likely to disturb the public order.

 

Preventive Detention: A Necessary Evil_50.1Get free video for UPSC CSE preparation and make your dream of becoming an IAS/IPS/IRS a reality

 

Constitutional provision

  • Article 22(1) and Article 22(2) of the constitution provides safeguards for the citizens against the misuse of preventive detention. It provides that
    • A person cannot be arrested and detained without being informed the grounds of his arrest.
    • A person who is arrested cannot be denied to be defended by a legal practitioner of his choice giving him/her the right to defend.
    • Every person who has been arrested need to be produced before the nearest magistrate within 24 hours.
    • The custody of the detained person cannot be beyond period authorised by the magistrate.

 

Why needed?

  • Complete personal liberty is neither possible nor desirable and restrictions on liberty for State’s security, public order, disruption of national economic discipline, is needed to ensure peace and stability of the society.
  • Separatist tendencies: To deal with this issue, strict laws are needed to ensure the indestructible nature of Indian Union. PD is one among those laws.
  • PD is not used in general. The number of persons detained in these acts is not large. It means due attention is made before arresting someone under preventive detention.
  • To maintain communal harmony in the highly diverse society is a complex affair. Laws like PD has a restraining influence on the anti-social and subversive elements.
  • Transnational crimes like hostile activities, espionage, coercion, terrorism, needs an effective instrument to deal with. PD ensures that the integrity and sovereignty of the State is maintained.

 

Supreme Court Verdict on 97th amendment

 

Issues

  • Instruments like PD is regressive and do not find place in the constitution of any democratic country.
  • Arbitrariness: Police determines whether a person poses a threat or not and it is not tested on a trial by leading evidence, neither it is examined by legally trained persons.
  • Violation of rights: It violates the Article 21 and Article 19 of Indian constitution, which forms the core of Fundamental Rights.
  • It has given wide scope to the administration to torture and practice discriminatory treatment. It does not restrict officials from misusing preventive detention for subversive activities.
  • In an unequal society, tools like PD are used against the socio-economically disadvantaged sections of society.

 

Way forward

  • As Supreme Court has said, PD is a necessary evil.
  • It might be, sometimes, at loggerheads with the Fundamental Rights. It, however, must function under the broad domain of constitutionalism, at all times.

Sharing is caring!

×

Download success!

Thanks for downloading the guide. For similar guides, free study material, quizzes, videos and job alerts you can download the Adda247 app from play store.

Thank You, Your details have been submitted we will get back to you.

Was this page helpful?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Login

OR

Forgot Password?

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Sign Up

OR
Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Forgot Password

Enter the email address associated with your account, and we'll email you an OTP to verify it's you.


Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Enter OTP

Please enter the OTP sent to
/6


Did not recive OTP?

Resend in 60s

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Change Password



Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Almost there

Please enter your phone no. to proceed
+91

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Enter OTP

Please enter the OTP sent to Edit Number


Did not recive OTP?

Resend 60

By skipping this step you will not recieve any free content avalaible on adda247, also you will miss onto notification and job alerts

Are you sure you want to skip this step?

By skipping this step you will not recieve any free content avalaible on adda247, also you will miss onto notification and job alerts

Are you sure you want to skip this step?