Correct option is B
The question "Have you given up your evil ways?" represents the
fallacy of a complex question (also called a
loaded question). This fallacy occurs when a question presupposes something that has not been established or agreed upon, often forcing the respondent into an implied admission of guilt or wrongdoing.
In this example:
· The phrase "your evil ways" presupposes that the person has committed immoral acts.
· Answering "yes" or "no" would implicitly concede the presupposition, making it impossible to answer without accepting the loaded assumption.
This fallacy is often used in arguments to trap the opponent into an admission, regardless of their response.
Information Booster:
1.
Complex Question Fallacy assumes a premise within a question that is contentious or unproven.
2. Examples of complex questions include:
· "Have you stopped cheating on your exams?"
· "Why do you hate the environment?"
3. It is often used in rhetoric to manipulate or trap individuals into an unfair position.
4. A valid response is to challenge the presupposition, rather than answer directly.
5. It differs from a
simple question, which does not contain hidden assumptions.
Additional Knowledge:
·
Irrelevant conclusion (Ignoratio Elenchi): This fallacy occurs when an argument fails to address the issue at hand and instead proves something unrelated.
·
False cause (Post hoc ergo propter hoc): This fallacy assumes a causal relationship between two events simply because one event follows another. Example: "Since I wore my lucky shirt, we won the game."
·
Petitio Principii (Begging the question): This fallacy occurs when the conclusion of an argument is assumed in its premises. Example: "God exists because the Bible says so, and the Bible is true because it is the word of God."