Correct option is C
The correct option is (c).
Option (c) is NOT a correct passive transformation because the passive sentence given as Sung by her is incomplete and does not follow the correct passive structure. A correct passive transformation must have a subject (object of active), an appropriate form of be, and the past participle (V3).
Step-by-step reasoning:
- Active sentence: She sings a song.
- Object of the active sentence: a song.
- In passive, the object becomes the subject: A song becomes the subject.
- Since the tense is simple present (sings), passive uses: is/am/are + V3.
- Correct passive should be: A song is sung by her.
Rule and structure:
- Active: Subject + V1/V2 + Object
- Passive (Simple Present): Object + is/am/are + V3 + by + Subject
Why other options are correct transformations:
- (a) We eat the cake → The cake is eaten by us (simple present passive structure is correct).
- (b) He gives her a gift can become A gift is given to her by him (one of the correct passive forms for double-object verbs).
- (d) They open the door → The door is opened by them (correct).
Information booster: In exams, incomplete passive forms without a clear subject and auxiliary verb are treated as incorrect even if the V3 is present.
So the correct answer is (c)