Correct option is B
Sentence B introduces the central idea—only one leaf remains, and Johnsy connects it to her own fate.
Sentence D follows naturally—an elderly artist, concerned about Johnsy, paints a leaf after the real one falls.
Sentence A comes next—it describes Johnsy’s reaction in the morning when she sees the leaf still there.
Sentence C concludes the paragraph, showing that Johnsy regained her will to live and recovered.