arrow
arrow
arrow
​According to classical Indian logicians (Naiyāyikas), which of the following arguments commits the fallacy of irregular middle?​
Question

According to classical Indian logicians (Naiyāyikas), which of the following arguments commits the fallacy of irregular middle?

A.

Sound is a quality because it is visible

B.

Sound is eternal because it is produced

C.

Sound is eternal because is is audible

D.

Fire is cold because it a substance

Correct option is C

Claim:"Sound is eternal (sādhya)."

Reason:"Because it is audible (hetu)."

Problem:

    Audibility (being heard)does not inherently imply eternality(being timeless).

    In Nyāya, eternality requires proof like"all-pervading"or"uncaused"—not mere perception.

    Thehetu("audible") isillogically pairedwithsādhya("eternal").

    Information booster 

    Irregular Middle: The hetu(middle term) fails to logically connect to the sādhya(major term).
    It is unproven (asiddha)or irrelevant to the conclusion.
    The hetu must necessarily and universally relate to thesādhya. Here, "audible" fails this test for "eternal."

    Free Tests

    Free
    Must Attempt

    Basics of Education: Pedagogy, Andragogy, and Hutagogy

    languageIcon English
    • pdpQsnIcon10 Questions
    • pdpsheetsIcon20 Marks
    • timerIcon12 Mins
    languageIcon English
    Free
    Must Attempt

    UGC NET Paper 1 Mock Test 1

    languageIcon English
    • pdpQsnIcon50 Questions
    • pdpsheetsIcon100 Marks
    • timerIcon60 Mins
    languageIcon English
    Free
    Must Attempt

    Basics of Education: Pedagogy, Andragogy, and Hutagogy

    languageIcon English
    • pdpQsnIcon10 Questions
    • pdpsheetsIcon20 Marks
    • timerIcon12 Mins
    languageIcon English

    Similar Questions

    test-prime-package

    Access ‘UGC NET June 2025’ Mock Tests with

    • 60000+ Mocks and Previous Year Papers
    • Unlimited Re-Attempts
    • Personalised Report Card
    • 500% Refund on Final Selection
    • Largest Community
    students-icon
    354k+ students have already unlocked exclusive benefits with Test Prime!
    Our Plans
    Monthsup-arrow