Correct option is B
- Wild-type T4 phages can grow on both E. coli B and K, forming small and ragged plaques.
- rII mutants:
- Can infect E. coli B, producing large, round plaques.
- Cannot infect E. coli K, meaning no plaques are formed.
Analysis of the Experiments
Experiment I:
- Co-infection of two independent rII mutants in E. coli K resulted in several plaques (all small and ragged).
- Since rII mutants alone cannot grow on E. coli K, the only explanation for the appearance of plaques is recombination.
- This suggests that at least some phages had wild-type recombinants, allowing them to grow on E. coli K.
Experiment II:
- E. coli B was co-infected with the same rII mutants.
- Phages from the resulting plaques (which would be a mix of wild-type and mutants) were used to infect E. coli K.
- Only a few plaques formed, all small and ragged, which indicates that:
- Recombination occurred in E. coli B to produce some wild-type phage, which could then infect E. coli K.
Evaluation of the Statements
(A) Experiment I indicates that the two mutants are allelic. (Incorrect)
- Allelic mutants mean that the mutations are in the same gene, so recombination would not restore wild-type function.
- However, plaques formed on E. coli K, which suggests that recombination did restore wild-type function, meaning the mutations were likely in different genes (not allelic).
(B) Experiment II indicates that the wild-type T4 phages that infected E. coli K resulted from a recombination event. (Correct)
- The appearance of a few small and ragged plaques on E. coli K suggests that some wild-type phage were recovered due to recombination between the rII mutants in E. coli B.
(C) In Experiment II, if the T4 phage isolated from E. coli B was used to infect E. coli B, all plaques would be large and round. (Incorrect)
- If recombination occurred, then the phage population would be a mix of wild-type and rII mutants.
- Wild-type phages would form small and ragged plaques, while rII mutants would form large and round plaques.
- Since a mixture of plaques would be observed (not all large and round), this statement is incorrect.
Information Booster
Key Concepts from This Experiment:
Plaque Morphology Indicates Phage Genotype:
- Wild-type T4 phages produce small and ragged plaques.
- rII mutants produce large and round plaques on E. coli B but *cannot grow on E. coli K (no plaques).
Recombination Restores Wild-Type Function:
- If two different rII mutants infect the same cell, crossing over can restore the wild-type gene sequence, allowing growth in E. coli K.
Complementation vs. Recombination:
- Complementation occurs when two mutations are in different genes and the combined gene products restore function in the same cell.
- Recombination restores wild-type function by crossing over between mutations.
Interpretation of Experimental Results:
- The presence of plaques on E. coli K suggests recombination occurred, producing wild-type phages.
- This confirms Statement B and refutes Statement A (which assumes allelic mutations).