arrow
arrow
arrow
Which of the following arguments is fallacious because of the middle term being too narrow?
Question



Which of the following arguments is fallacious because of the middle term being too narrow?

A.

All things are non-eternal because they are knowable

B.

Sound is eternal, because it is audible

C.

Fire is cold because it is substance

D.

Wherever there is fire, there is smoke

Correct option is B


The argument “Sound is eternal, because it is audible” is fallacious due to the middle term being too narrow.
In this argument:
· Middle term: "Audible"
· Major term: "Eternal"
· Minor term: "Sound"
The fallacy occurs because audibility (the middle term) is too narrow to logically establish that "sound is eternal." Just because something is audible does not imply it is eternal, as audibility applies to many things (like spoken words) that are not eternal.
Information Booster:
· (a) All things are non-eternal because they are knowable: The middle term "knowable" is broad enough to encompass all things that are non-eternal.
· (c) Fire is cold because it is substance: This is a fallacious argument, but not due to a narrow middle term. The middle term "substance" is overly broad, not narrow.
· (d) Wherever there is fire, there is smoke: This argument does not commit the fallacy of a narrow middle term. Fire generally produces smoke, and the middle term "fire" appropriately connects the concepts.
Additional Knowledge:
1. In syllogistic reasoning, the middle term must be broad enough to establish a logical connection between the major and minor terms.
2. A narrow middle term fails to cover the scope required to link the major and minor terms, leading to a logical fallacy.

Free Tests

Free
Must Attempt

Basics of Education: Pedagogy, Andragogy, and Hutagogy

languageIcon English
  • pdpQsnIcon10 Questions
  • pdpsheetsIcon20 Marks
  • timerIcon12 Mins
languageIcon English
Free
Must Attempt

UGC NET Paper 1 Mock Test 1

languageIcon English
  • pdpQsnIcon50 Questions
  • pdpsheetsIcon100 Marks
  • timerIcon60 Mins
languageIcon English
Free
Must Attempt

Basics of Education: Pedagogy, Andragogy, and Hutagogy

languageIcon English
  • pdpQsnIcon10 Questions
  • pdpsheetsIcon20 Marks
  • timerIcon12 Mins
languageIcon English
test-prime-package

Access ‘UGC NET December’ Mock Tests with

  • 60000+ Mocks and Previous Year Papers
  • Unlimited Re-Attempts
  • Personalised Report Card
  • 500% Refund on Final Selection
  • Largest Community
students-icon
353k+ students have already unlocked exclusive benefits with Test Prime!
Our Plans
Monthsup-arrow