Correct option is C
The families of formal languages can be arranged according to their expressive power, from the most specialized/restricted class to the most general/powerful class. Regular languages are the most restricted among the four, because every regular language can be recognized by a finite automaton.
Context-free languages are more expressive than regular languages because they can describe languages requiring constructs such as balanced parentheses. Turing-decidable languages are more powerful still, because a Turing machine that decides a language must halt on every input.
Finally, Turing-acceptable (recursively enumerable) languages form a broader class: a Turing machine is guaranteed to accept strings in the language but may run forever on strings outside it. Thus, the containment is A ⊂ D ⊂ C ⊂ B, giving A, D, C, B.
Information Booster
1. Hierarchy of the Language Families
The relevant hierarchy is:
Regular ⊂ Context-Free ⊂ Turing-Decidable ⊂ Turing-Acceptable
Therefore, A < D < C < B
This is a special case of the Chomsky hierarchy, extended beyond context-sensitive languages to distinguish decidable and recognizable languages.
2. Regular Languages — A
A regular language is a language that can be recognized by a finite automaton, such as:
· DFA — Deterministic Finite Automaton
· NFA — Nondeterministic Finite Automaton
Regular languages can also be represented using:
· Regular expressions
· Regular grammars
· Finite automata
For example:
is a regular language. Regular languages have limited memory, because a finite automaton has only a finite number of states.
Thus, among the given families, they are the most specialized/restricted:
A = Regular Languages
3. Context-Free Languages — D
A context-free language (CFL) is generated by a context-free grammar (CFG) and can be recognized by a pushdown automaton (PDA).
A standard example is:
This language is not regular, but it is context-free.
A PDA has a stack, giving it more memory capability than a finite automaton.
Therefore, Regular ⊊ Context-Free
4. Turing-Decidable Languages — C
A language is Turing decidable if there exists a Turing machine that:
· Accepts every string belonging to the language.
· Rejects every string not belonging to the language.
· Halts on every input.
Therefore, a decider always terminates.
For a language L, a decider M satisfies:
w ∈ L => M accepts w and w ∉ L => M rejects w with M halting in both cases.
Turing-decidable languages include all regular and context-free languages:
CFL ⊆ Decidable
Thus, A < D < C
5. Turing-Acceptable Languages — B
A Turing-acceptable language is also commonly called a:
· Turing-recognizable language
· Recursively enumerable (RE) language
A Turing machine recognizing such a language has the following behavior:
· If w ∈ L, it eventually accepts.
· If w ∉ L, it may reject or run forever.
The crucial difference is that the machine is not required to halt for every input.
Therefore, every decidable language is Turing-acceptable:
Decidable ⊆ Turing-Acceptable but the reverse is not true.
Thus, A < D < C < B
6. Why Turing-Acceptable Languages Are More General Than Decidable Languages?
Consider the halting problem:
HALT = {⟨M, w⟩∣M halts on w}
The halting problem is Turing-acceptable/recognizable, but it is not decidable.
A Turing machine can simulate M on w:
· If M halts, accept.
· If M never halts, the simulation continues forever.
Therefore, the language can be recognized but cannot be decided.
This demonstrates, Decidable ⊊ Turing-Acceptable
7. Comparison Table
Family | Typical Computational Model | Halting Requirement | Relative Power |
Regular (A) | Finite Automaton | Always halts | Lowest |
Context-Free (D) | Pushdown Automaton | Always halts for standard recognition procedures | Higher |
Turing Decidable (C) | Deciding Turing Machine | Must halt on every input | Higher |
Turing Acceptable (B) | Turing Machine Recognizer | May loop forever on non-members | Highest among these |
Hence, A ⊂ D ⊂ C ⊂ B
8. Chomsky Hierarchy Connection
The traditional Chomsky hierarchy is:
Regular ⊂ Context-Free ⊂ Context-Sensitive ⊂ Recursively Enumerable
The question additionally introduces Turing-decidable languages between context-free and Turing-acceptable languages:
Regular ⊂ Context-Free ⊂ Decidable ⊂ Turing-Acceptable