Recusal Of Judges_00.1
UPSC Exam   »   How to Prepare for UPSC CSE Mains Examination: Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners   »   Recusal Of Judges

Recusal Of Judges

 

Relevance

  • GS 2: Separation of powers between various organs, dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions.

 

Context

  •  Recently, a Delhi High Court judge recused himself from hearing a petition of digital media houses, which challenged the validity of the IT rules regulating intermediaries.
  • It is not a one-off case and, just a few days ago, two Supreme Court judges had recused themselves from hearing a plea relating to West Bengal.

 

Recusal of Judges: What it means?

  • Recusal or judicial disqualification means an act of abstention by any presiding court officer or an administrative officer from participating in an official action due to a conflict of interest.

 

Grounds for recusal

  • The judge is biased in favour of a litigant of any case.
  • The judge has an interest in the subject matter, either directly or indirectly.
  • The judge is having prior experience on the subject of litigation.
  • The judge knows the litigants personally.

 

What does the constitution say?

  • Article 14, under its due process of law, states that no one can be a judge of her own case. Owing to this cardinal feature, conflict of interest was accepted as a ground for recusal.

 

Recusal Of Judges_50.1Get free video for UPSC CSE preparation and make your dream of becoming an IAS/IPS/IRS a reality

 

Process of recusal

  • The decision of recusal is, generally, taken by the judge herself. There are no formal laws, which defines the process of recusal.
  • It is left on the conscience of judges to declare whether there is any potential conflict of interest arising from the litigation.
  • When a judge recuses, the case is listed before the Chief Justice for allotment to a fresh Bench.

 

 

Past Supreme Court judgements

Although there are no formal rules, several Supreme Court judgements have dealt with the issue.

  • Ranjit Thakur v Union of India (1987): In this case, the Supreme Court opined that the test of the likelihood of bias is the reasonableness of the apprehension in the mind of the parties to the litigation.
  • The 1999 charter ‘Restatement of Values in Judicial Life’— a code of ethics adopted by the Supreme Court—states, “A Judge shall not hear and decide a matter in a company in which he holds shares… unless he has disclosed his interest and no objection to his hearing and deciding the matter is raised”.

 

Legislative Council: A Complete Analysis

Issues with the recusal of judges

  • Frequent recusal of judges from the cases raises questions on the independence of the judiciary, a basic feature of our constitution.
  • Parties, sometimes, suggests that the judge should recuse herself from litigation. This precedent of judging the judge, without any significant evidence, is an alarming trend.
  • It allows parties to cherry-pick judge of their own choice.
  • The rule, which states that no one should be the judge of her own case, is subject to different interpretations. The conflict-of-interest clause is, at many times, misused.
  • Judges do not record the reasons for recusal in writing, leaving plenty of scope for conjecture.

 

Way forward

  • In 2015, Justice Kurian Joseph and Justice Madan Lokur, while holding the National Judicial Appointments Commission unconstitutional, stated the need for judges to give reasons for recusal to build transparency and help frame rules to govern the process.
  • Recusal must not become an instrument to navigate the justice delivery.
  • Judicial officers must resist all the pressure, no matter where they are coming from. It is what our constitution expects from them.
  • There is a need for definite and exhaustive rules, which deals specifically with this issue.

Sharing is caring!

×

Download success!

Thanks for downloading the guide. For similar guides, free study material, quizzes, videos and job alerts you can download the Adda247 app from play store.

Thank You, Your details have been submitted we will get back to you.

Was this page helpful?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Login

OR

Forgot Password?

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Sign Up

OR
Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Forgot Password

Enter the email address associated with your account, and we'll email you an OTP to verify it's you.


Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Enter OTP

Please enter the OTP sent to
/6


Did not recive OTP?

Resend in 60s

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Change Password



Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Almost there

Please enter your phone no. to proceed
+91

Join India's largest learning destination

What You Will get ?

  • Job Alerts
  • Daily Quizzes
  • Subject-Wise Quizzes
  • Current Affairs
  • Previous year question papers
  • Doubt Solving session

Enter OTP

Please enter the OTP sent to Edit Number


Did not recive OTP?

Resend 60

By skipping this step you will not recieve any free content avalaible on adda247, also you will miss onto notification and job alerts

Are you sure you want to skip this step?

By skipping this step you will not recieve any free content avalaible on adda247, also you will miss onto notification and job alerts

Are you sure you want to skip this step?